Ramadhani Juma
May 14
With examples discuss the merits and demerits of intrinsic and extrinsic reward in public organization?
Rewards ?
1 view
1 view
2 answers
Sort By
ChatGPT
May 14
Intrinsic rewards refer to the internal satisfaction or fulfillment that an individual gains from performing a task or achieving a goal. Examples of intrinsic rewards in a public organization could include a sense of accomplishment, personal growth, or the opportunity to contribute to the greater good of society. On the other hand, extrinsic rewards are tangible rewards that are provided by an external source, such as a salary increase, promotion, or recognition.
Merits of Intrinsic Rewards in Public Organizations:
1. Increased job satisfaction: Intrinsic rewards can lead to higher levels of job satisfaction as employees feel a sense of purpose and fulfillment in their work.
2. Improved motivation: Intrinsic rewards can be a powerful motivator for employees to perform at their best, as they are driven by personal satisfaction rather than external factors.
3. Enhanced creativity and innovation: Employees who are intrinsically motivated are more likely to think creatively and come up with innovative solutions to challenges.
4. Greater employee engagement: Intrinsic rewards can help to foster a sense of commitment and loyalty among employees, leading to higher levels of engagement and productivity.
Demerits of Intrinsic Rewards in Public Organizations:
1. Subjectivity: Intrinsic rewards are often subjective and can vary from person to person, making it difficult for organizations to consistently reward and motivate employees.
2. Lack of immediate gratification: Intrinsic rewards may not provide the same immediate gratification as extrinsic rewards, which can lead to lower levels of motivation in some employees.
3. Difficult to measure: It can be challenging for organizations to measure the impact of intrinsic rewards on employee performance and overall organizational success.
Merits of Extrinsic Rewards in Public Organizations:
1. Tangible incentives: Extrinsic rewards provide employees with tangible incentives, such as bonuses or promotions, that can motivate them to perform at a higher level.
2. Clear benchmarks for success: Extrinsic rewards are often tied to specific performance metrics, providing employees with clear benchmarks for success and achievement.
3. Attract and retain talent: Extrinsic rewards can help public organizations attract and retain top talent by offering competitive salaries and benefits.
Demerits of Extrinsic Rewards in Public Organizations:
1. Short-term focus: Extrinsic rewards can lead to a short-term focus on achieving specific goals or targets, rather than fostering long-term growth and development.
2. Potential for burnout: Excessive reliance on extrinsic rewards can lead to burnout and disengagement among employees, as they may feel pressured to constantly meet performance targets.
3. Limited impact on job satisfaction: Extrinsic rewards may not always lead to increased job satisfaction or motivation, as employees may become disillusioned if they feel that their efforts are only being rewarded with material incentives.
Merits of Intrinsic Rewards in Public Organizations:
1. Increased job satisfaction: Intrinsic rewards can lead to higher levels of job satisfaction as employees feel a sense of purpose and fulfillment in their work.
2. Improved motivation: Intrinsic rewards can be a powerful motivator for employees to perform at their best, as they are driven by personal satisfaction rather than external factors.
3. Enhanced creativity and innovation: Employees who are intrinsically motivated are more likely to think creatively and come up with innovative solutions to challenges.
4. Greater employee engagement: Intrinsic rewards can help to foster a sense of commitment and loyalty among employees, leading to higher levels of engagement and productivity.
Demerits of Intrinsic Rewards in Public Organizations:
1. Subjectivity: Intrinsic rewards are often subjective and can vary from person to person, making it difficult for organizations to consistently reward and motivate employees.
2. Lack of immediate gratification: Intrinsic rewards may not provide the same immediate gratification as extrinsic rewards, which can lead to lower levels of motivation in some employees.
3. Difficult to measure: It can be challenging for organizations to measure the impact of intrinsic rewards on employee performance and overall organizational success.
Merits of Extrinsic Rewards in Public Organizations:
1. Tangible incentives: Extrinsic rewards provide employees with tangible incentives, such as bonuses or promotions, that can motivate them to perform at a higher level.
2. Clear benchmarks for success: Extrinsic rewards are often tied to specific performance metrics, providing employees with clear benchmarks for success and achievement.
3. Attract and retain talent: Extrinsic rewards can help public organizations attract and retain top talent by offering competitive salaries and benefits.
Demerits of Extrinsic Rewards in Public Organizations:
1. Short-term focus: Extrinsic rewards can lead to a short-term focus on achieving specific goals or targets, rather than fostering long-term growth and development.
2. Potential for burnout: Excessive reliance on extrinsic rewards can lead to burnout and disengagement among employees, as they may feel pressured to constantly meet performance targets.
3. Limited impact on job satisfaction: Extrinsic rewards may not always lead to increased job satisfaction or motivation, as employees may become disillusioned if they feel that their efforts are only being rewarded with material incentives.
0
Google Gemini AI
May 14
Intrinsic Reward:
Merits:
- Increased motivation: Intrinsic rewards satisfy an individual's internal need for accomplishment, competence, and personal growth, leading to long-lasting motivation.
- Enhanced creativity and problem-solving: Intrinsic rewards encourage employees to engage in challenging tasks and develop innovative solutions.
- Increased job satisfaction: Employees who derive satisfaction from their work itself experience higher levels of overall job satisfaction.
Demerits:
- Limited applicability: Intrinsic rewards may not be effective for all employees or tasks. Individuals with strong external motivations may not be sufficiently driven by internal rewards.
- Subjectivity: Intrinsic rewards can be difficult to quantify and evaluate objectively, leading to potential biases or unfairness.
- Delayed gratification: Intrinsic rewards often come with delayed gratification, which may not be sustainable for long-term motivation.
Extrinsic Reward:
Merits:
- Immediate gratification: Extrinsic rewards provide tangible benefits that are immediately accessible, making them effective for short-term motivation.
- Clear performance indicators: Extrinsic rewards are linked to specific performance metrics, making it easy to track and reward desired behaviors.
- Fairness and equity: Extrinsic rewards can help ensure fairness by providing a standardized system for recognizing performance.
Demerits:
- Reduced intrinsic motivation: Reliance on extrinsic rewards can diminish intrinsic motivation, as employees may focus solely on the external incentives.
- Potential for unfairness or bias: Extrinsic rewards may be subject to favoritism or bias, leading to resentment and demotivation.
- High costs: Extrinsic rewards can be expensive to implement and maintain, especially if they involve financial incentives.
Example of Intrinsic and Extrinsic Rewards in Public Organizations:
Intrinsic reward: A social worker may experience a sense of fulfillment and accomplishment from helping disadvantaged individuals, even without receiving monetary compensation.
Extrinsic reward: A police officer may receive a promotion or a raise for achieving a high number of arrests or for successfully responding to critical incidents.
Merits:
- Increased motivation: Intrinsic rewards satisfy an individual's internal need for accomplishment, competence, and personal growth, leading to long-lasting motivation.
- Enhanced creativity and problem-solving: Intrinsic rewards encourage employees to engage in challenging tasks and develop innovative solutions.
- Increased job satisfaction: Employees who derive satisfaction from their work itself experience higher levels of overall job satisfaction.
Demerits:
- Limited applicability: Intrinsic rewards may not be effective for all employees or tasks. Individuals with strong external motivations may not be sufficiently driven by internal rewards.
- Subjectivity: Intrinsic rewards can be difficult to quantify and evaluate objectively, leading to potential biases or unfairness.
- Delayed gratification: Intrinsic rewards often come with delayed gratification, which may not be sustainable for long-term motivation.
Extrinsic Reward:
Merits:
- Immediate gratification: Extrinsic rewards provide tangible benefits that are immediately accessible, making them effective for short-term motivation.
- Clear performance indicators: Extrinsic rewards are linked to specific performance metrics, making it easy to track and reward desired behaviors.
- Fairness and equity: Extrinsic rewards can help ensure fairness by providing a standardized system for recognizing performance.
Demerits:
- Reduced intrinsic motivation: Reliance on extrinsic rewards can diminish intrinsic motivation, as employees may focus solely on the external incentives.
- Potential for unfairness or bias: Extrinsic rewards may be subject to favoritism or bias, leading to resentment and demotivation.
- High costs: Extrinsic rewards can be expensive to implement and maintain, especially if they involve financial incentives.
Example of Intrinsic and Extrinsic Rewards in Public Organizations:
Intrinsic reward: A social worker may experience a sense of fulfillment and accomplishment from helping disadvantaged individuals, even without receiving monetary compensation.
Extrinsic reward: A police officer may receive a promotion or a raise for achieving a high number of arrests or for successfully responding to critical incidents.
0
