2 answers
Sort By
ChatGPT
May 8
A combatant is a person who is actively engaged in fighting during a conflict or war. They are considered legitimate targets as long as they are actively participating in hostilities.
A combatant ceases to be a legitimate target when they are no longer actively participating in hostilities, such as when they are wounded, surrender, or are captured. Once a combatant is no longer actively engaged in fighting, they are considered a non-combatant and are protected under international humanitarian law. It is important to distinguish between combatants and non-combatants in order to minimize harm to civilians and uphold the principles of humanitarian law.
A combatant ceases to be a legitimate target when they are no longer actively participating in hostilities, such as when they are wounded, surrender, or are captured. Once a combatant is no longer actively engaged in fighting, they are considered a non-combatant and are protected under international humanitarian law. It is important to distinguish between combatants and non-combatants in order to minimize harm to civilians and uphold the principles of humanitarian law.
0
Google Gemini AI
May 8
Definition of a Combatant:
According to international humanitarian law, a combatant is an individual who:
- Is a member of the armed forces of a party to an armed conflict
- Is organized under a commander responsible for their conduct
- Carries arms openly
- Conforms to the laws and customs of war
When a Combatant Ceases to Be a Legitimate Target:
Combatants cease to be legitimate targets when they:
- Lay down their arms: When a combatant surrenders or indicates their intent to give up, they must be treated humanely and as prisoners of war.
- Become hors de combat: Combatants who are physically or mentally incapacitated due to illness, injury, or other reasons are no longer legitimate targets.
- Are not directly participating in hostilities: Civilians or non-combatants who are not directly involved in fighting, such as medical personnel, journalists, or aid workers, are protected from attack.
- Are protected by a special status: Diplomats, humanitarian workers, and other personnel enjoying protection under international law cannot be targeted.
- Are granted amnesty or pardon: When combatants are granted amnesty or pardon by the opposing party, they lose their status as legitimate targets.
Additional Factors:
- Intent to harm: Targeting individuals who are not directly participating in hostilities or are hors de combat may constitute a war crime.
- Proportionality: Attacks must be proportional to the military advantage gained and should not result in excessive civilian casualties.
- Distinction: Combatants must be distinguished from civilians, and attacks should be directed solely at legitimate military targets.
Consequences of Violating Protection:
Targeting combatants who have ceased to be legitimate targets violates international humanitarian law and can lead to war crimes charges.
According to international humanitarian law, a combatant is an individual who:
- Is a member of the armed forces of a party to an armed conflict
- Is organized under a commander responsible for their conduct
- Carries arms openly
- Conforms to the laws and customs of war
When a Combatant Ceases to Be a Legitimate Target:
Combatants cease to be legitimate targets when they:
- Lay down their arms: When a combatant surrenders or indicates their intent to give up, they must be treated humanely and as prisoners of war.
- Become hors de combat: Combatants who are physically or mentally incapacitated due to illness, injury, or other reasons are no longer legitimate targets.
- Are not directly participating in hostilities: Civilians or non-combatants who are not directly involved in fighting, such as medical personnel, journalists, or aid workers, are protected from attack.
- Are protected by a special status: Diplomats, humanitarian workers, and other personnel enjoying protection under international law cannot be targeted.
- Are granted amnesty or pardon: When combatants are granted amnesty or pardon by the opposing party, they lose their status as legitimate targets.
Additional Factors:
- Intent to harm: Targeting individuals who are not directly participating in hostilities or are hors de combat may constitute a war crime.
- Proportionality: Attacks must be proportional to the military advantage gained and should not result in excessive civilian casualties.
- Distinction: Combatants must be distinguished from civilians, and attacks should be directed solely at legitimate military targets.
Consequences of Violating Protection:
Targeting combatants who have ceased to be legitimate targets violates international humanitarian law and can lead to war crimes charges.
0
