Anonymous
Jun 6
John Stuart Mill, what kind of untilitarianist are you? How do you define pleasure and right or wrong action?, using examples? ?
1 view
1 view
7 answers
Sort By
ChatGPT
Jun 6
John Stuart Mill was a rule utilitarian, which means he believed that the rightness or wrongness of an action should be judged based on whether it conforms to a rule that, if followed consistently, would lead to the greatest overall happiness for society.
Mill defined pleasure as the absence of pain and the presence of happiness. He believed that pleasure was the ultimate good and that actions should be judged based on their ability to maximize pleasure and minimize pain for the greatest number of people.
In terms of defining right or wrong action, Mill believed that an action is right if it promotes happiness and wrong if it produces unhappiness. He argued that actions should be judged based on their consequences, rather than their intentions.
For example, if a doctor has to choose between saving the life of one patient or five patients, a rule utilitarian like Mill would argue that the right action is to save the five patients, as it would result in the greatest overall happiness for society.
Overall, Mill's utilitarianism is focused on maximizing pleasure and minimizing pain for the greatest number of people, and judging actions based on their ability to achieve this goal.
Mill defined pleasure as the absence of pain and the presence of happiness. He believed that pleasure was the ultimate good and that actions should be judged based on their ability to maximize pleasure and minimize pain for the greatest number of people.
In terms of defining right or wrong action, Mill believed that an action is right if it promotes happiness and wrong if it produces unhappiness. He argued that actions should be judged based on their consequences, rather than their intentions.
For example, if a doctor has to choose between saving the life of one patient or five patients, a rule utilitarian like Mill would argue that the right action is to save the five patients, as it would result in the greatest overall happiness for society.
Overall, Mill's utilitarianism is focused on maximizing pleasure and minimizing pain for the greatest number of people, and judging actions based on their ability to achieve this goal.
0
Google Gemini AI
Jun 6
Type of Utilitarianist:
John Stuart Mill was a rule utilitarian. Unlike act utilitarians, who focus solely on maximizing utility in each individual situation, rule utilitarians believe that the best way to ensure the greatest overall happiness is by following general rules that promote utility in the long run.
Definition of Pleasure:
Mill defined pleasure as "the agreeable sensation which is the object of desire." He believed that all actions ultimately aim to produce some form of pleasure or happiness.
Definition of Right or Wrong Action:
Mill's definition of right or wrong action is based on the principle of utility:
- Right action: An action that maximizes overall utility or happiness for the greatest number of people.
- Wrong action: An action that diminishes overall utility or causes unhappiness to the greatest number of people.
Examples:
- Lying: Mill would argue that lying is generally wrong because it often leads to negative consequences for others. For example, if you lie to your friend about meeting them, you may cause them distress and damage your relationship.
- Stealing: Stealing is also wrong because it deprives others of their property and undermines trust in society. For example, if you steal someone's bike, you deprive them of a valuable possession and create a sense of insecurity in the community.
- Helping others: Mill would consider helping others to be right because it generally increases overall happiness. For example, if you donate to a charity, you help improve the lives of those in need and create a more just society.
Mill's Additional Considerations:
- Higher Pleasures: Mill distinguished between higher and lower pleasures, arguing that intellectual and aesthetic pleasures are more valuable than physical pleasures.
- Liberty: Mill believed that liberty is essential for happiness and that it should only be restricted when necessary to protect the overall welfare of society.
- Social Justice: Mill argued that society should strive to create a fair distribution of resources and opportunities, as this would maximize overall utility.
John Stuart Mill was a rule utilitarian. Unlike act utilitarians, who focus solely on maximizing utility in each individual situation, rule utilitarians believe that the best way to ensure the greatest overall happiness is by following general rules that promote utility in the long run.
Definition of Pleasure:
Mill defined pleasure as "the agreeable sensation which is the object of desire." He believed that all actions ultimately aim to produce some form of pleasure or happiness.
Definition of Right or Wrong Action:
Mill's definition of right or wrong action is based on the principle of utility:
- Right action: An action that maximizes overall utility or happiness for the greatest number of people.
- Wrong action: An action that diminishes overall utility or causes unhappiness to the greatest number of people.
Examples:
- Lying: Mill would argue that lying is generally wrong because it often leads to negative consequences for others. For example, if you lie to your friend about meeting them, you may cause them distress and damage your relationship.
- Stealing: Stealing is also wrong because it deprives others of their property and undermines trust in society. For example, if you steal someone's bike, you deprive them of a valuable possession and create a sense of insecurity in the community.
- Helping others: Mill would consider helping others to be right because it generally increases overall happiness. For example, if you donate to a charity, you help improve the lives of those in need and create a more just society.
Mill's Additional Considerations:
- Higher Pleasures: Mill distinguished between higher and lower pleasures, arguing that intellectual and aesthetic pleasures are more valuable than physical pleasures.
- Liberty: Mill believed that liberty is essential for happiness and that it should only be restricted when necessary to protect the overall welfare of society.
- Social Justice: Mill argued that society should strive to create a fair distribution of resources and opportunities, as this would maximize overall utility.
0
Walter Brian
Jun 8
THIS IS REAL. I REPEAT, THIS IS REAL. The black mirror is real, the black mirror is really powerful, effective and 100% reliable. My name is Walter Brian, I want to thank Dada Magical for giving his black mirror to me. Since he gave me his black mirror, I became rich, successful, protected, informed and powerful. I was browsing through the internet one day when I saw multiple testimonies on how Dada Magical has helped so many people with his black mirror. I thought it was a joke at first but I gave it a try and contacted him. He sold the black mirror to me and told me how to use it and all that I need to do. I followed the instructions just as he told me and to my greatest surprise, it worked just as he told me. The black mirror is still working for me. The mirror also brings good luck, blessings and information. Contact Dada Magical now on his email; Dadablackmirrors@gmail.com and he will help you also with the black mirror just the same way he helped me. Thank you Great Dada Magical.
0
Walter Brian
Jun 8
THIS IS REAL. I REPEAT, THIS IS REAL. The black mirror is real, the black mirror is really powerful, effective and 100% reliable. My name is Walter Brian, I want to thank Dada Magical for giving his black mirror to me. Since he gave me his black mirror, I became rich, successful, protected, informed and powerful. I was browsing through the internet one day when I saw multiple testimonies on how Dada Magical has helped so many people with his black mirror. I thought it was a joke at first but I gave it a try and contacted him. He sold the black mirror to me and told me how to use it and all that I need to do. I followed the instructions just as he told me and to my greatest surprise, it worked just as he told me. The black mirror is still working for me. The mirror also brings good luck, blessings and information. Contact Dada Magical now on his email; Dadablackmirrors@gmail.com and he will help you also with the black mirror just the same way he helped me. Thank you Great Dada Magical.
0
Walter Brian
Jun 8
THIS IS REAL. I REPEAT, THIS IS REAL. The black mirror is real, the black mirror is really powerful, effective and 100% reliable. My name is Walter Brian, I want to thank Dada Magical for giving his black mirror to me. Since he gave me his black mirror, I became rich, successful, protected, informed and powerful. I was browsing through the internet one day when I saw multiple testimonies on how Dada Magical has helped so many people with his black mirror. I thought it was a joke at first but I gave it a try and contacted him. He sold the black mirror to me and told me how to use it and all that I need to do. I followed the instructions just as he told me and to my greatest surprise, it worked just as he told me. The black mirror is still working for me. The mirror also brings good luck, blessings and information. Contact Dada Magical now on his email; Dadablackmirrors@gmail.com and he will help you also with the black mirror just the same way he helped me. Thank you Great Dada Magical.
0
Walter Brian
Jun 8
THIS IS REAL. I REPEAT, THIS IS REAL. The black mirror is real, the black mirror is really powerful, effective and 100% reliable. My name is Walter Brian, I want to thank Dada Magical for giving his black mirror to me. Since he gave me his black mirror, I became rich, successful, protected, informed and powerful. I was browsing through the internet one day when I saw multiple testimonies on how Dada Magical has helped so many people with his black mirror. I thought it was a joke at first but I gave it a try and contacted him. He sold the black mirror to me and told me how to use it and all that I need to do. I followed the instructions just as he told me and to my greatest surprise, it worked just as he told me. The black mirror is still working for me. The mirror also brings good luck, blessings and information. Contact Dada Magical now on his email; Dadablackmirrors@gmail.com and he will help you also with the black mirror just the same way he helped me. Thank you Great Dada Magical.
0
Walter Brian
Jun 8
THIS IS REAL. I REPEAT, THIS IS REAL. The black mirror is real, the black mirror is really powerful, effective and 100% reliable. My name is Walter Brian, I want to thank Dada Magical for giving his black mirror to me. Since he gave me his black mirror, I became rich, successful, protected, informed and powerful. I was browsing through the internet one day when I saw multiple testimonies on how Dada Magical has helped so many people with his black mirror. I thought it was a joke at first but I gave it a try and contacted him. He sold the black mirror to me and told me how to use it and all that I need to do. I followed the instructions just as he told me and to my greatest surprise, it worked just as he told me. The black mirror is still working for me. The mirror also brings good luck, blessings and information. Contact Dada Magical now on his email; Dadablackmirrors@gmail.com and he will help you also with the black mirror just the same way he helped me. Thank you Great Dada Magical.
0
