Compare and contrast deontological and teleological ethics, using example?

Deontological ethics, also known as duty-based ethics, focuses on the inherent rightness or wrongness of actions themselves, rather than the consequences of those actions. This ethical theory is based on the idea that individuals have a moral duty to act in certain ways, regardless of the outcomes of their actions. In deontological ethics, actions are judged based on whether they adhere to certain moral principles or rules, such as the categorical imperative proposed by Immanuel Kant.

On the other hand, teleological ethics, also known as consequentialist ethics, focuses on the outcomes or consequences of actions. This ethical theory holds that the morality of an action is determined by its consequences, with the goal of maximizing overall happiness or well-being. Utilitarianism is a well-known example of teleological ethics, which states that the right action is the one that produces the greatest amount of happiness for the greatest number of people.

To illustrate the difference between deontological and teleological ethics, consider the following scenario: a doctor is faced with the decision of whether to euthanize a terminally ill patient who is in excruciating pain. According to deontological ethics, the doctor would be morally obligated to uphold the principle of preserving life and not intentionally causing harm, regardless of the potential relief from suffering that euthanasia could provide. On the other hand, a teleological ethicist might argue that euthanizing the patient would be morally justified if it ultimately leads to the reduction of suffering and an increase in overall well-being for the patient and their loved ones.

Deontological Ethics

- Focuses on the rightness or wrongness of actions based on their inherent nature, not their consequences.
- Emphasizes duty, obligation, and respect for moral rules.
- Believes that certain actions are intrinsically good or evil, regardless of their outcomes.

Example:

- Stealing is always wrong, regardless of whether it benefits someone.

Teleological Ethics

- Focuses on the consequences of actions and judges them based on the overall good they produce.
- Aims to maximize happiness, well-being, or utility.
- Believes that the right action is the one that produces the most good.

Example:

- If stealing food from a store is the only way to prevent someone from starving, then it may be considered morally acceptable.

Comparison

1. Basis of Morality:

- Deontology: Inherent nature of actions
- Teleology: Consequences of actions

2. Role of Rules:

- Deontology: Rules are absolute and provide clear guidance for actions.
- Teleology: Rules are less important than maximizing overall good.

3. Consider Consequences:

- Deontology: Consequences are not the primary focus.
- Teleology: Consequences are essential for ethical decision-making.

4. Role of Intentions:

- Deontology: Intentions are irrelevant if the action itself is immoral.
- Teleology: Intentions can mitigate ethical concerns if the consequences are positive.

5. Flexibility:

- Deontology: Rules are inflexible and apply universally.
- Teleology: Rules can be flexible if they compromise overall well-being.

Contrast

1. Absolute vs. Relative Morality:

- Deontology: Morality is absolute and unchanging.
- Teleology: Morality can be relative to circumstances and outcomes.

2. Emphasis on Duty vs. Happiness:

- Deontology: Focuses on fulfilling duties and obligations.
- Teleology: Emphasizes maximizing overall happiness and well-being.

3. Treatment of Minorities:

- Deontology: May protect minority rights even if it does not maximize overall happiness.
- Teleology: May prioritize majority interests if it produces greater overall good.

THIS IS REAL. I REPEAT, THIS IS REAL. The black mirror is real, the black mirror is really powerful, effective and 100% reliable. My name is Walter Brian, I want to thank Dada Magical for giving his black mirror to me. Since he gave me his black mirror, I became rich, successful, protected, informed and powerful. I was browsing through the internet one day when I saw multiple testimonies on how Dada Magical has helped so many people with his black mirror. I thought it was a joke at first but I gave it a try and contacted him. He sold the black mirror to me and told me how to use it and all that I need to do. I followed the instructions just as he told me and to my greatest surprise, it worked just as he told me. The black mirror is still working for me. The mirror also brings good luck, blessings and information. Contact Dada Magical now on his email; Dadablackmirrors@gmail.com and he will help you also with the black mirror just the same way he helped me. Thank you Great Dada Magical.

THIS IS REAL. I REPEAT, THIS IS REAL. The black mirror is real, the black mirror is really powerful, effective and 100% reliable. My name is Walter Brian, I want to thank Dada Magical for giving his black mirror to me. Since he gave me his black mirror, I became rich, successful, protected, informed and powerful. I was browsing through the internet one day when I saw multiple testimonies on how Dada Magical has helped so many people with his black mirror. I thought it was a joke at first but I gave it a try and contacted him. He sold the black mirror to me and told me how to use it and all that I need to do. I followed the instructions just as he told me and to my greatest surprise, it worked just as he told me. The black mirror is still working for me. The mirror also brings good luck, blessings and information. Contact Dada Magical now on his email; Dadablackmirrors@gmail.com and he will help you also with the black mirror just the same way he helped me. Thank you Great Dada Magical.

THIS IS REAL. I REPEAT, THIS IS REAL. The black mirror is real, the black mirror is really powerful, effective and 100% reliable. My name is Walter Brian, I want to thank Dada Magical for giving his black mirror to me. Since he gave me his black mirror, I became rich, successful, protected, informed and powerful. I was browsing through the internet one day when I saw multiple testimonies on how Dada Magical has helped so many people with his black mirror. I thought it was a joke at first but I gave it a try and contacted him. He sold the black mirror to me and told me how to use it and all that I need to do. I followed the instructions just as he told me and to my greatest surprise, it worked just as he told me. The black mirror is still working for me. The mirror also brings good luck, blessings and information. Contact Dada Magical now on his email; Dadablackmirrors@gmail.com and he will help you also with the black mirror just the same way he helped me. Thank you Great Dada Magical.

THIS IS REAL. I REPEAT, THIS IS REAL. The black mirror is real, the black mirror is really powerful, effective and 100% reliable. My name is Walter Brian, I want to thank Dada Magical for giving his black mirror to me. Since he gave me his black mirror, I became rich, successful, protected, informed and powerful. I was browsing through the internet one day when I saw multiple testimonies on how Dada Magical has helped so many people with his black mirror. I thought it was a joke at first but I gave it a try and contacted him. He sold the black mirror to me and told me how to use it and all that I need to do. I followed the instructions just as he told me and to my greatest surprise, it worked just as he told me. The black mirror is still working for me. The mirror also brings good luck, blessings and information. Contact Dada Magical now on his email; Dadablackmirrors@gmail.com and he will help you also with the black mirror just the same way he helped me. Thank you Great Dada Magical.

THIS IS REAL. I REPEAT, THIS IS REAL. The black mirror is real, the black mirror is really powerful, effective and 100% reliable. My name is Walter Brian, I want to thank Dada Magical for giving his black mirror to me. Since he gave me his black mirror, I became rich, successful, protected, informed and powerful. I was browsing through the internet one day when I saw multiple testimonies on how Dada Magical has helped so many people with his black mirror. I thought it was a joke at first but I gave it a try and contacted him. He sold the black mirror to me and told me how to use it and all that I need to do. I followed the instructions just as he told me and to my greatest surprise, it worked just as he told me. The black mirror is still working for me. The mirror also brings good luck, blessings and information. Contact Dada Magical now on his email; Dadablackmirrors@gmail.com and he will help you also with the black mirror just the same way he helped me. Thank you Great Dada Magical.

THIS IS REAL. I REPEAT, THIS IS REAL. The black mirror is real, the black mirror is really powerful, effective and 100% reliable. My name is Walter Brian, I want to thank Dada Magical for giving his black mirror to me. Since he gave me his black mirror, I became rich, successful, protected, informed and powerful. I was browsing through the internet one day when I saw multiple testimonies on how Dada Magical has helped so many people with his black mirror. I thought it was a joke at first but I gave it a try and contacted him. He sold the black mirror to me and told me how to use it and all that I need to do. I followed the instructions just as he told me and to my greatest surprise, it worked just as he told me. The black mirror is still working for me. The mirror also brings good luck, blessings and information. Contact Dada Magical now on his email; Dadablackmirrors@gmail.com and he will help you also with the black mirror just the same way he helped me. Thank you Great Dada Magical.